One of the main problems in the crisp and fuzzy ahp method is the issue of inconsistency in the dms opinions. The analytic hierarchy process the analytic hierarchy process ahp, introduced by thomas saaty 1980, is an effective tool for dealing with complex decision making, and may aid the decision maker to set priorities and make the best decision. The fundamental concept of fuzzy set priority relation, r, is derived from the result obtained by shannon 1986 method. Assessment of energy systems using extended fuzzy ahp.
The analytic hierarchy process ahp is one of the most widelyused multiattribute decisionmaking methods. Analytical hierarchy process ahp is one of the best ways for deciding among the complex criteria structure in different levels. The foundation of the analytic hierarchy process ahp is a set of axioms that carefully delimits the scope of the problem environment saaty 1986. Fuzzy ahp method 21, 22, 23 systematically solves the selection problem that uses the concepts of fuzzy set theory and hierarchical structure analysis. The diversity of types of gemstones and consumers becomes an obstacle in itself when the knowledge and ability of individuals to analyze the quality of gemstones is minimal. Fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and its application. We proposed a group of decisionmakers based on fuzzy ahp. Likewise an ahp, fuzzy ahp provides a hierarchical structure, facilitates the decompositions and pairwise comparisons, reduces the inconsistency and generates the priority vectors. The analytic hierarchy process ahp is a multicriteria decisionmaking approach and was introduced by saaty 1977 and 1994. By applying the principle of the comparison of fuzzy numbers, that is, vm1. A hybrid method of fuzzy dematelahpvikor approach to.
Comparison of the fuzzy ahp method, the spatial correlation method, and the dong model to predict the. Fuzzy ahp approach as a support to the decision making process concerning engagement of the group for additional hindering darko bozanic, dragan pamucar and dragan bojanic military academy, university of defence in belgrade. Pdf fuzzy ahp has been popular multi criteria decision making approach having varied application. By developing the mathematical models, defining and quantifying the bvce indices, and analyzing the factors that influence blasting vibration comfort in a hierarchical manner, this study proposes an exploratory fuzzy ahp based method for comprehensive bvce. Selecting a cruise port of call location using the fuzzy. It is based on the well defined mathematical structure of consistent matrices and their associated eigenvectors ability to generate true or approximate weights, saaty 1980, 1994. Pdf operating system selection using fuzzy ahp and topsis. In this paper, the comparison of classical ahp and fuzzy ahp on a case study that is constructed for the same hierarchy structure and criteria set. In this study we used ahp and fuzzyahp method to evaluate individual restaurant alternatives. Over the time, several modifications of the method for fuzzy environment have been devised. In this article, by using fuzzy ahp and topsis technique we propose a new method for project selection problem.
Tesfamariam, solomon and sadiq, rehan, 2006, riskbased environmental decisionmaking using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process fahp. Classical ahp ahp is a mathematical technique used for multicriteria decisionmaking. Software tool implementing the fuzzy ahp method in ecological risk assessment. Information security risk analysis methods and research trends. Ahp and fuzzy comprehensive method mingchang lee national kaohsiung university of applied science, taiwan abstract information security risk analysis becomes an increasingly essential component of organizations operations. Fuzzy analytic hierarchy process ahp proves to be a very useful methodology for multiple criteria decisionmaking in fuzzy environments, which has found substantial applications in recent years. Leung and cao 2000 developed a model to test the consistency in fuzzy ahp. Application of analytical hierarchy process ahp technique. This paper aims at comparing the classical ahp and fuzzy ahp, to show the. Selecting a cruise port of call location using the fuzzyahp.
Strategy selection in the universities via fuzzy ahp. A fuzzy ahpbased method for comprehensive blasting. The reciprocal value of an assigned score is the inverse of that. Using analytic hierarchy process method to prioritise human resources in substitution problem, international journal computer internet management, vol. In classical ahp, we use the 19 scale to evaluate the criteria or alternatives in pairwise comparison matrices. Ahp software software used to solve analytic hierarchy process ahp in decision making and operation research. An application of fuzzy ahp for evaluating students project. This method is different from the traditional fahp,which used to facilitate the pairwise comparison process and avoid the complex and unreliable process of comparing fuzzy utilities. The decisionmaking method used is fuzzy analytical hierarchy process f ahp method which is widely. Basically, fuzzy ahp method represents the elaboration of a standard ahp method into fuzzy domain by using fuzzy numbers for calculating instead of real numbers 24. Applications of the extent analysis method on fuzzy ahp. A hybrid method of fuzzy dematelahpvikor approach to rank.
The ahp has attracted the interest of many researchers mainly due to the nice mathematical properties of the method and the fact that the required input data are rather easy to obtain. In a way it is better than other multicriteria techniques, as it was designed to incorporate tangible as well as. Decision support on the extent analysis method for fuzzy ahp and its applications yingming wang a, ying luo b, zhongsheng hua c a school of public administration, fuzhou university, fuzhou 350002, pr china b school of management, xiamen university, xiamen 361005, pr china c school of management, university of science and technology of china, hefei 230026, pr china. The analytical hierarchy process ahp approach which was developed by saaty 1980, saaty 1977 possesses distinct advantage of dealing with subjective information of decision makers dms. Application of the fuzzy delphi method and the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process for the managerial competence of multinational corporation executives. This study intended to combine the fuzzy analysis model and ahp to evaluate the ev of yrd in a method called fuzzy analytic hierarchy process fahp. The ahp method became very popular in multiplecriteria decisionmaking and it found its applications in diverse fields. Fuzzy ahp is a synthetic extension of classical ahp method when the fuzziness of the decision makers is considered.
Fuzzy analytic hierarchy process fuzzy ahp generate group integration. Analytical hierarchy process ahp and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method are coupled to form a new approach named fuzzyahp. Fuzzy analytical hierarchy process method to determine the. Software tool implementing the fuzzy ahp method in. Application of the fuzzy delphi method and the fuzzy. The approaches allow the decision maker to use experts. A fuzzyahp multicriteria decision making model for procurement.
Compmat is comparision matrix of alternate attributes. Over the time, several modifications of the method for fuzzy environment. The results demonstrated that trapezoidal fuzzy ahp trafahp could. Fuzzy analytical network process implementation with matlab. Useing fuzzy ahp and topsis method for project selection free download as powerpoint presentation. Saaty 1980 referred to weaknesses resulting from this problem and provided a consistency test for crisp ahp.
Useing fuzzy ahp and topsis method for project selection. The fuzzy ahp approach was used for clarifying the weight of criteria and fuzzy vikor and topsis were utilized for ordering the alternative energy systems according to their investment priority. In this section we overview the fuzzy ahp methods existing in the literature. The vast majority of the applications use a crisp point estimate method such as the extent analysis or the fuzzy preference programming fpp based. Furthermore, wang and chin 2008 proposes a sound yet simple priority method for fuzzy ahp which utilizes a linear goal programming model to derive normalized fuzzy weights for fuzzy pairwise comparison matrices. As one of the most outstanding multi criteria decision making mcdm approach saaty et al. Comparison of fuzzy ahp and fuzzy todim methods for.
A free software tool implementing the fuzzy ahp method, proceedings of the 34th international conference on mathematical methods in economics 2016, liberec, czech republic, p. In this paper, changs extent analysis was utilized for selecting ports of call in east asia. The coupled method fuzzyahp applys to solve multicriteria. The decisionmaking method used is fuzzy analytical hierarchy. Pdf application of the extent analysis method on fuzzy. By reducing complex decisions to a series of pairwise comparisons, and then. Operating system selection using fuzzy ahp and topsis methods article pdf available in mathematical and computational applications 142. Analytical hierarchy process ahp is a powerful decisionmaking methodology for calculating the weights and priority of different criteria. Ecological vulnerability assessment based on fuzzy. The weight of each index is determined using the analytic hierarchy process. In classical ahp, we use the 19 scale to evaluate the criteria or alternatives in pairwise comparison. Chang, dayong, 1996, applications of the extent analysis method on fuzzy ahp. On the extent analysis method for fuzzy ahp and its.
It represents an accurate approach for quantifying. Ecological vulnerability assessment based on fuzzy analytical. The fuzzy priority is computed and compared with the rank order of the other methods. By developing the mathematical models, defining and quantifying the bvce indices, and analyzing the factors that influence blasting vibration comfort in a hierarchical manner, this study proposes an exploratory fuzzy ahpbased method for comprehensive bvce. Jie 2010 applied fuzzy ahp to evaluate online course quality. In section 3, three numerical examples are examined using the extent analysis method to show its serious problems and irrationalities. Fuzzy sets theory is utilized to cover the vagueness inherent in the nature of project selection problem as well. The proposed methodology is based on analytical hierarchy process.
Strategy selection in the universities via fuzzy ahp method. View combination fuzzy ahp and mcdm method with arcgis 10 research papers on academia. The objective of this paper is to apply the extension of ahp, namely fuzzy ahp 79, in order to handle the fuzziness of data involved in mcdm problem of this study. Saaty, 2008 or a weight estimation technique vaidya and kumar. One widely used method which can handle both group decisions and fuzziness is the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process ahp a further development of saatys widely used ahp technique saaty, 1980. Comparison of the fuzzy ahp method, the spatial correlation.
Mcdm methods have been introduced based on fuzzy analytic hierarchy process ahp for 2tuple linguistic representation model. Mieselb aforest research division, research institute of forests and rangelands, agricultural research, education and. Assessment of energy systems using extended fuzzy ahp, fuzzy. Comparison of fuzzy ahp and fuzzy todim methods for landfill. In second step of the research, to select appropriate software, ahp method is used for weighting and fuzzy vikor method is used to select the best erp system. Chang 1996 proposed a new method with the use of triangular fuzzy numbers and extent analysis method for the pairwise comparison scale of ahp and the synthetic extent values of the pairwise comparisons, respectively. Furthermore, many ahp methods developed by various authors can be found in literature.
A multicriteria decisionmaking approach based on fuzzy ahp with. Application of the fuzzy delphi method and the fuzzy analytic. Pdf a free software tool implementing the fuzzy ahp method. A fuzzy ahpbased method for comprehensive blasting vibration. There are many approaches on solution processes with the fuzzy ahp method. Pdf operating system selection using fuzzy ahp and. A hybrid method of fuzzy dematelahpvikor approach to rank and select the best hospital nurses of a years. Information security risk analysis methods and research. A study on fuzzy ahp method and its applications in a tie. Saaty in the 1970s who partnered with ernest forman to develop expert choice in 1983, and has been extensively studied and refined since then. Review of the extent analysis method on fuzzy ahp consider a triangular fuzzy comparison matrix. Pdf a study on fuzzy ahp method and its applications in a tie. In this methodology by utilizing improved analytical hierarchy process by.
Applying fuzzy analytic hierarchy process to evaluate and. A fuzzy ahp approach for selection of measuring instrument. A fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method based on ahp and. A case study seyede narges taati1, ayda esmailidooki 2 1 department of industrial engineering, babol noshirvani university of technology, iran 2department of industrial engineering, firoozkooh branch, islamic azad university, iran p a p e r i n f o a b s t r a c t. Conventional multiple attribute decision making methods cannot effectively handle problems with such imprecise information. In this paper, a new methodology or approach is proposed for dealing with the tie situation, which is based on fuzzy analytical hierarchy. The results obtained from the study have shown that epicor system is the most appropriate and the best system to be. Performance analysis of hospital managers using fuzzy ahp. The paper introduces a new free software tool that implements one of these approaches. This method should be used in situations when both weights and input data are fuzzy. The analytic hierarchy process ahp is a structured technique for organizing and analyzing complex decisions, based on mathematics and psychology. In this study we used ahp and fuzzy ahp method to evaluate individual restaurant alternatives.
A fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method based on ahp. Questionnaires were analyzed by fahp method and it was concluded that the most important strategy for the university is to be in the countrys top 5 universities and in the worlds top 500 universities. Application of the extent analysis method on fuzzy ahp. Ahp and fuzzy comprehensive method mingchang lee national kaohsiung university of applied science, taiwan abstract information security risk analysis becomes an increasingly essential component of. Evaluation of firms applying to malcolm baldrige national. A fuzzyahp method for selection best apparel item to startup. Fuzzy ahp is a synthetic extension of classical ahp method when the fuzziness of the decision maker is considered. Fuzzy analytic hierarchy process ahp is one of the multicriteria decision making methods which are widely used in modeling unstructured problems arisen in fields like politics, economics, social and management sciences saaty, 1980. On the other hand, sensitivity analysis was carried out to determine the priority of investment for energy systems and comparison of them using the. Supplier selection, fuzzy ahp, multi criteria decision making. On the extent analysis method for fuzzy ahp and its applications. Using ahp technique and fuzzy vikor technique to select a. We present the four different approaches of fuzzy ahp methods by giving numerical examples. In this section, fuzzy ahp method is proposed for the same problem of the landfill location selection in casablanca region.
The method for fuzzy ahp consists of the following six steps. Second function is consistencyahp with oneoutput variable and one input variable. Software tool implementing the fuzzy ahp method in ecological risk assessment andrejs radionovs a. Analytic hierarchy process, selection criteria, fuzzy sets. Software tool implementing the fuzzy ahp method in ecological. Pdf application of the extent analysis method on fuzzy ahp.
They illustrated its application for a supplier selection problem. Trafahp method for accurately identifying cash crop suitability. There are many approaches on solution processes with the fuzzyahp method. A study on fuzzy ahp method and its applications in a tiebreaking. Other studies tended to use the ahp to evaluate the ev of yrd, but the arti. The selection of quality gemstones requires a special ability to select and assess the quality of gemstones to be traded. Analytical hierarchy processahp and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method are coupled to form a new approach named fuzzyahp.
1513 1270 877 633 1296 7 76 1400 1334 838 766 316 1088 451 594 368 1414 68 1111 570 45 400 231 1001 804 581 516 547 490 704 1498 739 239 590 322 176 1016 644 721 834 234 880 61 531 325 1071 1286 837